We’re fortunate to be blessed with a large variety of cutting methods and devices in the cigar world and the choice of cutter is a fun topic to debate. While some cigar enthusiasts appreciate the punch cutter for its convenience and precision, many tobacconists have a less favorable view of this tool. Let’s talk about why certain tobacconists are not fans of using a punch cutter for cigars.

The Case for a Punch Cutter

A punch cutter is designed to create a small hole in the cap of a cigar, rather than slicing off the end as a straight cutter does. This method offers a more concentrated and restricted draw, which can be ideal for certain types of cigars and personal preferences.

Click the image above to learn how to cut every type of cigar

If I’ve personally identified a cigar with a more open draw than I prefer, I’ll reach for the punch cutter next time to tailor the experience to my preferences. This is particularly useful in the occasional box-pressed cigar. 

Tobacconists' Concerns with Punch Cutters

• Limited Draw: One of the primary concerns of using the punch cutter regularly is the restricted airflow caused by the small opening. Even if the cigar is expertly punched, customers may not be satisfied with the draw. Tobacconists are keen to maximizing satisfaction while mitigating risks of disappointment. 
• Not Suitable for All Cigars: Punch cutters are less versatile compared to straight cutters. They are not ideal for smaller ring gauge cigars or certain cigar shapes like figurados. There are neat things you can do with a punch cutter and box-pressed or chisel shaped cigars, though, and you can read more about them here.
• Prone to Damaging the Cigar: This style requires a bit more skill than a lot of cutters and punching a cigar with a single cap (think Padrón) usually results in disaster. If your shop has a lot of turnover, punch cutters are harder to properly train staff to use as well.
• Risk of Tar Build-Up: The narrow opening of a punch cut can lead to an accumulation of tar, especially towards the end of the cigar. This can result in an extremely bitter taste that may turn a new cigar enthusiast off to the experience.
• Less Control Over the Cut: Punch cutters may come in slightly different sizes, but the options remain limited.
• Harder to Double Tap: If you select a V-cut and need a more open draw, it’s easy to cut again to form an X or + sign in your cigar. A straight cut is also easy enough to perform again if needed. A punch cut, however, makes it difficult to re-punch or even follow up with a different cutter. Usually I see people using their finger nails to widen the opening which exposes unwanted little bits of tobacco.
• Easy to Lose: whether on accident or actual malfeasance, the fact is that most punch cutters are extremely small and prone to walking away from the shop. Even for personal use, it seems like these cutters disappear much more frequently than other devices. 

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the choice of cutter should be influenced by the type of cigar, desired smoking experience, and personal preferences. Despite the criticisms, punch cutters will always have a place in the growing world of cigar accessories. 

Click the image above to read more about flying with cigars and accessories

My favorite way to use a punch cutter is while traveling with a lighter that has a built-in punch accessory. I always have another cutter in my checked bag as well, but you’d be surprised how often this comes in handy despite the concerns listed above. 

As always, there are plenty of supporters of the punch cut! If you’d like to chime in below and cover any points I missed or criticize the criticism, please don’t hesitate to add your thoughts.